February 17, 2025

5 Important Tips for Finding a Great Behavioral Health Provider

Finding the right behavioral health provider can feel overwhelming. These tips will help you choose someone who truly understands your mental health needs.

Frame 1077241738Clinically Reviewed by Nate Bush,LCSW

behavioral health provider

Table of Contents

Looking for a behavioral health provider can feel like searching for a white cat in a snowstorm—frustrating, exhausting, and even more challenging when you’re already struggling.

If you are dealing with anxiety, feeling down, or working on recovery, the right provider makes all the difference.

The good news? You’re not alone, and there are a few methods that can help you find someone you click with.

I’ve put together some tips to help make this process feel a bit more doable.

Why Finding the Right Behavioral Health Provider Actually Matters

Think of it like finding a good friend—someone who really gets you and knows how to help when it feels like everything is falling apart.

The best mental health professional is much more than someone with fancy diplomas decorating their wall (not that that doesn’t matter, too!).

Instead, they’re someone who listens, validates your feelings, and helps you hang onto hope when all else seems bleak. With the right provider, therapy becomes a safe haven in which you can be yourself, process challenges, and develop the skills you will need to recover.

5 Tips for Choosing the Best Behavioral Health Provider

The task of finding an ideal provider doesn’t have to be an uphill battle. It’s far less intimidating when you take things one step at a time.

This way, you won’t feel like you have to tackle it all at once.

Let’s jump into each of these 5 tips below so you can feel confident about choosing someone right for you.

1. Look for Licensed and Qualified Professionals

Check their credentials, but don’t stop there!

Of course, you do want someone who knows their stuff. Look for the telltale letters, like LCSW or LPC, at the ends of their names that indicate their background.

These tell you they’ve done the work to help you properly.

But remember, credentials are just the starting point.

It’s like having a driver’s license; it means you can drive, but it doesn’t automatically make you the right person to trust with your road trip.

2. Evaluate Their Specializations and Experience

Look for someone who specializes in your needs. This is a must!

If you’re dealing with something specific like anxiety or addiction recovery, you’ll want someone who knows that territory inside and out.¹

It’s sort of like taking your car to the mechanic.

Most can work on cars, but wouldn’t you want someone who knows the nitty-gritty details about your make and model?

3. Consider Compatibility and Communication Style

As you search, trust your instincts about your comfort level.

This is a huge deal, and I can’t stress it enough.

You have to be comfortable with this person so that you can be open with them.

During your first meeting, pay attention to how you feel.

Do they listen to you without making you feel judged?

Do they explain everything in a way that makes sense to you?

You’re not being picky – you’re being smart about your mental health care!²

4. Assess Their Availability and Location, and Insurance Coverage

Compatibility is undoubtedly important, but don’t neglect the more practical details.

I’m talking about the everyday details that can make or break your commitment to therapy.

Can you realistically get to their office without it being a huge hassle?

Do their available times work with your schedule?

Do they take your insurance?

Many facilities will help you sort out the insurance stuff before you even start, which can save you some major headaches later.³

Pro Tip: Cornerstone will verify your insurance for you for free!

5. Look into Patient Reviews and Testimonials

While everyone’s experience is different, taking a few minutes to sift through reviews can give you a good feel for what to expect.

Look for comments about people’s feelings during their sessions, not just the end results.

Did they feel respected? Supported? Understood?

Remember that even the greatest providers will have a few not-so-great reviews, but take note of overall trends.

Quick Tip: Trust Your Journey When Finding Support

Remember that finding the right behavioral health provider is a process, not a race. Start by reaching out to one or two providers who specialize in what you need. Pay attention to how you feel during your first conversation – that gut feeling matters more than you might think. It’s okay to take your time finding someone who gets you.

How to Make Your Decision

Here’s something people don’t talk about enough—it’s completely fine to take your time with this decision.

It’s also okay to try someone out and decide they’re not the right fit.

You’re not hurting anyone’s feelings by looking for the best match for you.

Ask yourself what matters most to you as a provider.

Maybe it’s their communication style, their take treatment, or even just the vibe you get from them.

If you aren’t feeling it, it’s okay.

And if you are, that’s great!

In either scenario, make sure you are being honest with yourself about your impressions from the outset because you deserve the best care possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I look for in a behavioral health provider?

Think of finding a provider, like choosing a trusted guide for your journey. You’ll want someone with the right credentials who knows their stuff but also someone who gets you. Look for proper licenses and qualifications, sure, but don’t forget to trust your instincts about whether you feel comfortable talking with them.

Just like you’d want a heart doctor for heart problems, having someone who really knows your specific challenges makes a huge difference. A provider who specializes in what you’re going through will have the right tools and experience to help you move forward successfully.

Pay attention to how you feel during your first conversation with a provider. Do they really listen and explain things clearly? The right person will make you feel heard and understood, not judged. It’s like finding someone who speaks your language!

Vector note 1,

Key Takeaways

Find the Right Behavioral Health Provider at Cornerstone

While finding a mental health professional can be quite an adventure, every step you take will help bring you closer to a brighter tomorrow.

At first, this might seem like an overwhelmingly daunting task, but keep in mind that your ideal provider is out there—someone who gets you and supports you and will help you move towards your goals.

Giving yourself time to figure that out isn’t just okay; it’s one of the best things you can do for yourself.

Here at Cornerstone Healing Center, we know that everyone’s path to healing looks different.

That’s why we offer a range of options, including residential care, flexible outpatient programs, and virtual sessions that fit your life.

Our team of caring professionals works with you to create a personalized approach that matches your needs and schedule, whether you’re looking for intensive support or regular check-ins to keep you on track.

We’re here to walk alongside you on your journey to better mental health, providing you with the best care possible.

Share this Article

Author & Reviewers

lionel estrada lisac clinical director
CLINICAL DIRECTOR & REVIEWER

Lionel is the Clinical Director of Cornerstone’s Scottsdale treatment facilities. He has had over 4 years at Cornerstone. He is personally in recovery and passionate about helping others overcome substance abuse and mental health challenges; he is trained as an EMDR, adopting a trauma-informed approach to treat the underlying issues.

More From Our Resources

Mental Health

Therapy for Caregivers: Finding Support When You Need It

Mental Health

Exploring a Holistic Approach to OCD with Acupuncture

Virtual IOP

Virtual IOP vs. Traditional IOP: Which is Right for You?